Stop n Shop is open 24 hours every day, so the schedule gives full flexibility. That makes it a strong stop for early coffee, late snacks, or a quick meal after hours. Reviews point to morning visits as a sweet spot, since one regular has made it a morning coffee stop for years. If you want the classic rhythm of the place, I would aim for the morning crowd.
For a first visit, I would start with a Cuban coffee or a cortadito. Reviews keep pointing to both, and they show the coffee side of the shop at its best. If you want food with it, empanadas or a Cuban sandwich are the clear names to know. That mix gives you the shop's core in one visit.
The reviews also say this is a place for fast service. That helps when you need to get in, order, and move on with the day. At the same time, the store can feel crowded when you want to sit, since one review says most of the seating is gone. So this works best as a quick stop rather than a long stay.
Accessibility is a plus here. The brief lists a wheelchair-accessible car park and a wheelchair-accessible entrance. Those details make the visit easier for more people in the downtown area. The location near the First Street Metromover station also makes the shop easy to reach for commuters and city walkers.
One thing to keep in mind is the price display issue raised in the reviews. A guest noted that prices were not shown, and that bothered them. If price visibility matters to you, it is worth checking before you commit. Even so, many regulars keep coming back for the coffee, the food, and the staff who make the stop feel local and known.